Members of the Westminster Planning and Zoning Commission said Thursday that traffic is not a reason to reject the proposed Village Square apartment building, and most said they would not require the developer to include one-bedroom units.

The commission took no vote at the Nov. 19 work session. It continued its review of the project to its Dec. 17 meeting, when members plan to take up the building's design, the site layout and how residents would walk to nearby destinations.

Village Square LLC, in care of Ernest Rafailides, wants to replace about 32 existing apartments at 102 Wimert Avenue, near Sullivan Avenue and MD 140, with a five-story building containing 120 two-bedroom apartments and about 9,100 square feet of ground-floor commercial space, according to the city staff report.

The proposal was introduced to the commission in May. The request, Local Map Amendment LMA 25-01, would place the city's Compatible Neighborhood Overlay Zone over the property's existing R-7,500 residential zoning, allowing more density than the current zoning permits.

A rendering from revised plans submitted Nov. 9 shows the proposed Village Square building from Sullivan and Wimert avenues, with a sidewalk and on-street parking added along the street. (Zavos Architecture + Design, via City of Westminster)

The commission acts in an advisory role. After it finishes its review, it will send a recommendation to the mayor and Common Council, which has final say over the zoning change. A detailed site plan would require a separate approval later.

Thursday's meeting was the commission's third scheduled work session on the project since a public hearing in August. The second, in October, was largely put off after the applicant asked to reschedule. At that meeting, members raised questions about the traffic study and about the mix of unit sizes, and they set this session to focus on those topics.

What the traffic study found

The applicant's traffic study, prepared by Lenhart Traffic Consulting and included in the commission's packet, found that every studied intersection would operate at level of service D or better, the threshold Carroll County and the State Highway Administration consider acceptable. A traffic engineer from the firm told commissioners the study had been reviewed and approved by the State Highway Administration, the county and the city.

The intersection with the longest delays in the study is MD 140 and Sullivan Road, which already operates at level D. According to the study, the average delay for a vehicle there during the morning peak hour is 35.6 seconds today. It is projected to reach 36.9 seconds by the time the project is built because of regional growth and other approved developments, and 37.7 seconds with Village Square added. In the evening peak, the figures are 35.8 seconds today, 38.3 seconds projected without the project and 39.2 seconds with it.

That means the project itself would add less than a second of delay at MD 140 and Sullivan Road. The study's tables show similarly small increases elsewhere; the largest is 1.1 seconds at Sullivan and Shaeffer avenues, where the average delay would remain under 4 seconds. The engineer said an intersection would not drop to level E until average delay reaches 55 seconds.

The study used standard trip-generation rates from the Institute of Transportation Engineers rather than the lower rates available for walkable downtown locations, the engineer said. The study also estimated the commercial space's traffic using rates for a strip shopping center, which it describes as conservative, and the engineer said no reduction was taken for trips by residents who would shop downstairs. Following the national standard, the study estimates traffic by the number of units rather than the number of bedrooms.

Commission member Robert Wack noted that most cars at the major intersections near the site are passing through the neighborhood rather than starting or ending there. The engineer agreed, pointing to the study's morning counts at Sullivan Avenue and Pennsylvania Avenue, where 399 vehicles traveled south and 201 north on Pennsylvania Avenue, while 46 turned onto Pennsylvania from Sullivan.

Daniel Hoff, a Westminster city councilman who sits on the commission, said residents raise traffic concerns about nearly every project, but that the study showed the impact was not significant enough to give the commission a reasonable basis to turn the project down on traffic alone. Other commissioners said they did not have a traffic concern. The project would face traffic review again at the site plan stage.

One-bedroom units

Hoff argued that the building should include some one-bedroom apartments. He said a mix of unit sizes would better serve the community, and that the commission has the authority to ask for it because it is not required to apply the overlay zone to the property.

Other members disagreed. Wack called it an overreach to dictate what is essentially a market decision. Others said two-bedroom units tend to have less turnover, suit people who share rent or work from home, and are more marketable.

Kelly Miller, the attorney representing Rafailides, said the existing units on the site and the owner's other properties nearby are all two-bedroom, and that the owner has had success with that model. Rafailides could not attend because of a family emergency, Miller said.

City planning staff said the unit mix falls within the commission's review because the overlay decision turns on a project's impacts, including how many people would live there and what that means for schools and parks.

After the discussion, Hoff acknowledged that he was the only member who wanted one-bedroom units and said he would not raise the issue again at the next work session.

Crossing MD 140

The possibility of a pedestrian crossing at MD 140 and Sullivan Road came up in State Highway Administration comments on the project, according to discussion at the meeting.

Miller and the traffic engineer said a crossing there would likely be unsafe or impractical. They cited the intersection's angle, high-speed right-turn lanes, a median too narrow for a pedestrian refuge and the need for new signal equipment. The engineer said rebuilding a traffic signal can cost as much as $750,000, and that any change would need state approval. The commissioners who spoke said they would not require a crossing as a condition of the project.

Revised plans and what's still open

The applicant submitted a revised conceptual plan on Nov. 9 with changes to the site layout, open space and parking, according to the staff report. City staff said at the meeting that the revisions add sidewalks, curb bump-outs with on-street parking, street trees and a central open space. The building's architecture is unchanged.

A rendering from revised plans submitted Nov. 9 shows a central green space with a plaza at Village Square's main entrance, replacing some parking shown in the original plan. (Zavos Architecture + Design, via City of Westminster)

Commissioners said the Dec. 17 work session should cover the building's appearance, the site layout and pedestrian connections, including the lack of a sidewalk from the site to Pennsylvania Avenue and a route to Dutterer Family Park, about 1,500 feet away. The staff report says there is currently no defined or safe walking route to the park.

Two issues raised in the city's staff report got little or no attention Thursday. Staff have asked the applicant to explain the occupancy of the existing apartments and its plan to relocate current residents; that request was not discussed.

Water came up only briefly, when Hoff mentioned the city's limited water supply during the unit-mix debate. Wack said water was a valid public-impact argument for the commission to weigh, unlike personal preferences about the types of units.

The report shows the project would need 18,455 gallons per day of water and sewer allocation. The city's allocation chart has 3,890 gallons per day available this year in its inside-city multifamily category, and 48,930 gallons per day in its general water and sewer fund categories.